Showing posts with label WADA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WADA. Show all posts

Wednesday, 5 November 2014

Dumb sports law

Along with ‘Dumb Criminals’ ‘Dumb Laws’ are an internet staple.  I do not know the source for these Daily Telegraph ones but suspect some are wrong or misunderstandings and am confident that some of these are definitely wrong.

So let’s add some Dumb Sport’s Law to the mix.  Sport is often accused of being behind the curve - and never likely to catch up - on doping.  As a criminologist I’m inclined to a harm reduction perspective on drugs in society so would be for sport too.

Claiming a harm reduction motive as well as seeking to prevent performance enhancement WADA are now seeking to get in front of the curve by banning the gases xenon and argon.  As the BBC news website points out in its headline, this despite having no test for the gases!  Obviously outside of sport we’ve had subjective tests for sobriety but these have been replaced by accurate measures of alcohol in breath or blood - not same thing, as drunk drivers argue.

The BBC article points out that some doubt the benefits. They quote Dr Ben Koh who notes they are not banning the use of hypoxic tents and suggests the gases may be safer.  Moreover, Dr Chris Cooper suggests any benefit may not work in the way WADA suggest.  However, Russian medicine seems very keen on the benefits and the BBC noted the approval then of the Russian Olympic committee.

Also as a relativist, sceptic and low level athlete I incline to the view that if you take vitamins or pray because you believe it will help your performance then you are attempting to cheat.  Athletes try all the latest training methods, supplements etc.  Some are legal, some are illegal and some are legal but become illegal and less often vice versa.


If WADA could throw its weight behind proving the inefficacy of vitamins or banning them for efficacy that might be interesting.  And a test for the power of prayer?

no word yet on Krypton.

Tuesday, 5 June 2012

My pseudoephedrine, caffeine and diclofenac shame: ‘drug cheats’, ‘performance-enhancing’ or ‘performance-enabling’?


As a one-time marathoner I have risked being banned for my use of pseudoephedrine, in an over the counter cold remedy.  Was I a drug cheat?  I would argue no, since no amount of drug use would have enabled me to win.  I had a cold and, risking my health, decided to enable my performance by using a ‘performance-enhancing’ drug.  I’d done the training, I wanted to do the race.
My best Marathon (London 1985, 3hours 1min 34 seconds) followed 2 years of 50 miles a week, 3 weeks without alcohol, one week without tea or coffee and a super strong cup of black coffee on the morning of the marathon.  Caffeine is on the World Anti Doping Agency’s (WADA) permitted list but it’s use is monitored.
All this running has come back to haunt me in the form of osteoarthritis in my legs.  An ongoing prescription for diclofenac (sold as Voltarol) followed diagnosis.  It fights inflammation and pain and allowed me to continue running.  Concern for my health - ie that its use was masking further damage to my knees, hips and toes - means I’m currently ‘clean’ and exercising with pain.
I have criminological doubts about sport’s ‘War on Drugs’ and will write about it  shortly in an Olympic Special but my own legal, ‘monitored’ and banned drug use meant I was also recently interested in FIFAs recent concern about painkillers.
In the British Journal of Sports Medicine Tscholl and Dvorak report that during the tournament 71.7% of all players took medication, and 60.3% (444 of 736 players) took painkilling agents at least once. Over a third of players (39.0%) took a painkilling agent before every game!  Some of that would have been my  little helper, diclofenac.
I worry that this is bad for their health.  Dr Geyer of WADA is reported to be concerned about the rise of the use of painkillers in training and competition.  But says:
The very extensiveness of societal caffeine acceptance/abuse has largely kept it out of anti-doping regimes and completely out of media chants of ‘drug cheat’.  Might an arthritic generation accept diclofenac abuse and the rave generation yet more recreational use and use in recreation?